Sensational-Adelaide.com

Patrick_27 wrote: ↑

Wed Jul 17, 2019 10:41 pm

Ben wrote: ↑

Wed Jul 17, 2019 10:36 am

New application is about to be lodged. Waiting on further information. Fingers crossed its not student accom.

Personally see nothing wrong with it being student accommodation, just hope it's not another shit design. Would like to see the neighbouring site get a wriggle on, had a lot of ground level activation that this section of North Terrace needs.

Yeah, the 199-200 North Tce proposal is high on my wishlist for the city too, although more for enlivening the Gawler Place link to the Mall than anything it'd do for North Tce. Ideally, 203 and 199/200 would be consolidated sites to truly transform North Tce. But whatever comes next, I hope it's more considerate of the heritage below and designed in-the-round (esp. no blank eastern face).

Alterations and additions to a State Heritage Place and a multistorey student accommodation tower.

And there it is. No surprise really. the thing with these types of building is they have almost always been of poor design and cater to a large amount of people in a small space who are there temporarily and do not care about the surrounding environs.

I'll await the renders before i start screaming but this should in my opinion be an up market shopping precinct.

Ben wrote: ↑

Thu Jul 18, 2019 8:40 am

Alterations and additions to a State Heritage Place and a multistorey student accommodation tower.

And there it is. No surprise really. the thing with these types of building is they have almost always been of poor design and cater to a large amount of people in a small space who are there temporarily and do not care about the surrounding environs.

I'll await the renders before i start screaming but this should in my opinion be an up market shopping precinct.

Good design, upmarket shopping and student apartments needn't be mutually exclusive though I'll admit our city's track record doesn't inspire confidence. A silver lining might be that, as student apartments, this building won't require car parking nor balconies (which in many recent developments have become polluted with laundry, storage and ugly furniture - not ideal for a North Tce vantage). Presumably, also, students will help support a nighttime economy in the surrounding precinct. Fingers crossed for an exceptional outcome.

Ben wrote: ↑

Thu Jul 18, 2019 8:40 am

Alterations and additions to a State Heritage Place and a multistorey student accommodation tower.

And there it is. No surprise really. the thing with these types of building is they have almost always been of poor design and cater to a large amount of people in a small space who are there temporarily and do not care about the surrounding environs.

I'll await the renders before i start screaming but this should in my opinion be an up market shopping precinct.

100% agree- hopefully we are both wrong.

If the design is as bad as the last proposal they may as well just bash the heritage building down. If that had gone ahead the tackiness of it would have basically destroyed any heritage value anyway.

Any idea who the developer is? I’m surprised Le Cordon Bleu (next door) didn’t buy it as this student accom. building would partially block the view of the proposed towers to be built behind it (if it ever happens).

Another 100m+ This will be 33 levels.

Ben wrote: ↑

Tue Jul 30, 2019 10:29 am

Another 100m+ This will be 33 levels.

What's the source on that?

I hope this isn't 33 levels of concrete.

I hope the developers behind this, show some respect to the fact this building will be on North Terrace.

Another Dwell or the Cheese would look atrocious.

Will wrote: ↑

Tue Jul 30, 2019 10:40 am

I hope this isn't 33 levels of concrete.

I hope the developers behind this, show some respect to the fact this building will be on North Terrace.

Another Dwell or the Cheese would look atrocious.

Agreed. If it's a student accom we aren't going to get something amazing, but at a minimum the standard of the Urbanest Adelaide Uni accommodation should be required.

Nort wrote: ↑

Tue Jul 30, 2019 10:31 am

Ben wrote: ↑

Tue Jul 30, 2019 10:29 am

Another 100m+ This will be 33 levels.

What's the source on that?

ACC updated the description.

I also am nervous on this one given the lowbudget for such proposals. This is the first time a heritage building will be incorporated into a student accom building.

Application Number: S10/32/2019
Type: Schedule 10
Lodged: 17/07/2019
Location: 203-205 North Terrace, ADELAIDE SA 5000
Description: Alterations and additions to a State Heritage Place and the construction of a 33 storey student accommodation tower

If the design was something along the lines of the Hines Twin Street proposal, that would be great. Due to the highly prominent location of this tower, I'd hope there's some decent architectural expression here.

Cheers.

Glad this one isn't slipping through the cracks. The heritage building is beautiful but empty and needing to be used.

An interesting one to watch for sure.

From the SA Planning commission website.

I did not think anyone could possibly design something uglier than Dwell, until this thing came along.

I have been involved in Adelaide developments for over 20 years, and this is by far the worst proposal I have seen.

It is a cheap, vile, monstrosity, that belongs in some third world communist hell-hole. Most definitely not on North Terrace!

Hope this gets rejected.