[COM] Re: South Road Upgrades | PRO: South Road Superway
Posted: Tue Jul 20, 2010 12:11 pm
Is it just me or can you guys see how everything's slowly coming together for a North-South freeway piece by piece?
Adelaide's Premier Development and Construction Site
https://mail.sensational-adelaide.com/forum/
https://mail.sensational-adelaide.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=263
I think those of us with a big picture view remarked something similar about two years ago.iTouch(myself) wrote:Is it just me or can you guys see how everything's slowly coming together for a North-South freeway piece by piece?
A little bit, but a lot of the increased traffic predictions are for commercial traffic that will be mostly outside of peak hours and also will be exiting South Road before ever reaching the Port Road area.JamesXander wrote:I can understand why they are doing it, but it is very frustrating that they are going to solve a 'future' problem, but the fact remains if traffic is going to increase to the north of South Rd, won't that mean even more traffic on South rd, meaning further delays on the already mind numbingly slow parts?
South Rd upgrade back on agenda
UPGRADING South Rd between the Superway and Gallipoli Underpass is back on the State Government’s agenda but funding and a construction timeframe are yet to be approved.
The Government will soon call for tenders to plan a multi-million dollar upgrade of about 9km of South Rd, between the superway in the north and the underpass at Anzac Highway.
The section includes some of the narrowest parts of South Rd and is lined with businesses and homes, presenting one of the biggest challenges in the quest to convert the key route into a 22km free-flowing north-south road transport corridor.
In April last year, the RAA unveiled its vision of a $2 billion, 6km tunnel from the underpass to north of the Outer Harbor rail line at Croydon.
At the time, Transport Minister Patrick Colon said a tunnel would be ‘‘incredibly expensive’’ and a ‘‘big ask’’ but did not rule it out.
Ok so stupid question: what would be more expensive to elevate the entire stretch and connect to the already built superway or to build a tunnel? Because of the total supeway 3Km is elevated and the forecast cost for the project is circa $900mil. So which would be more cost effective (assuming that either option achieves the same end efficiency)?muzzamo wrote:From the advertiser today:
South Rd upgrade back on agenda
UPGRADING South Rd between the Superway and Gallipoli Underpass is back on the State Government’s agenda but funding and a construction timeframe are yet to be approved.
The Government will soon call for tenders to plan a multi-million dollar upgrade of about 9km of South Rd, between the superway in the north and the underpass at Anzac Highway.
The section includes some of the narrowest parts of South Rd and is lined with businesses and homes, presenting one of the biggest challenges in the quest to convert the key route into a 22km free-flowing north-south road transport corridor.
In April last year, the RAA unveiled its vision of a $2 billion, 6km tunnel from the underpass to north of the Outer Harbor rail line at Croydon.
At the time, Transport Minister Patrick Colon said a tunnel would be ‘‘incredibly expensive’’ and a ‘‘big ask’’ but did not rule it out.
On a purely financial measure, elevating it would probably be cheaper. But elevating major roads through residential areas would be politically unpopular with good reason - they're noisy, unsightly, and divide communities.Benski81 wrote:Ok so stupid question: what would be more expensive to elevate the entire stretch [N of the Gallipoli Underpass] and connect to the already built superway or to build a tunnel? Because of the total supeway 3Km is elevated and the forecast cost for the project is circa $900mil. So which would be more cost effective (assuming that either option achieves the same end efficiency)?
But this would mean that the road would be grade separated at the intersections only, ie entrance to premises would be at grade.Aidan wrote:A better solution would be 4 overpasses, the tunnel / long underpass under the railway, Port Road and Grange Road including provision for traffic to go under the railway only, 3 other underpasses, and numerous bridges (probably about 10 plus a few footbridges).