Page 2 of 6

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| ~52m | 13 Levels | Office

Posted: Tue Oct 21, 2008 4:59 pm
by Mants
are plans/renders available :?

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 1:00 pm
by Ben
This building is to recieve council support on Monday's Council Meeting.

Another bland pod style box with a blank western facade from Woods Bagot. Recycling the same old designs. Really dissapointing.

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 1:13 pm
by Shuz
*Yawn*

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 1:41 pm
by cruel_world00
Shuz wrote:*Yawn*

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 1:45 pm
by Snorkie
Oh God Damn It! Are Woods Bagot the most useless architects or what? Its bad enough CC is going to be the most generic, boring arse block in the city, but we dont need an entire street of the same crap!!! I want a redesign please. Hate these western blank walls. How dissapointing.

The only positive is that the building its gonna replace is an absolut disgrace. Probably one of the worst buildings in that central CBD area, cant wait to see it go.

From what I can see its clearly 13 levels not 12 (including ground floor). Any mention of how much office space Ben? Looks pretty massive, and am guessing its gonna have 20,000+m of space, cause the block is pretty long.

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 1:53 pm
by frank1
I never understood why architects are so hell bent on this western blank wall shit. It is so dam ugly :evil:

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 1:54 pm
by Howie
Snorkie wrote:Oh God Damn It! Are Woods Bagot the most useless architects or what? Its bad enough CC is going to be the most generic, boring arse block in the city, but we dont need an entire street of the same crap!!! I want a redesign please. Hate these western blank walls. How dissapointing.
In their defence, developers have to pay for iconic designs, what can they do if the developer won't budget for that? Also you can't really blame them for blank western walls.. they can't exactly change building regs. It's pretty easy for us to criticise their work but without walking a mile in their shoes....

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 2:16 pm
by Pikey
I like it!

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 2:44 pm
by Ben
Snorkie wrote: Any mention of how much office space Ben? Looks pretty massive, and am guessing its gonna have 20,000+m of space, cause the block is pretty long.
Yep 23,200sqm

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 2:49 pm
by Norman
I don't mind it, at least it's 100% better than the current eyesore that is there.

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 2:54 pm
by Just build it
Wow, how attractive and original. :roll:

I can't believe there's a team of architects at that place that can sit down and agree that these featureless Lego monstrosities are the best they can come up with, regardless of the budget.

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 2:57 pm
by omada
Ok yes yes it's of the same ilk as the CC development, but I rather like it, its modern! I'm not blown away about it of course, and i'm sure i'll get shot down for this, but look fellow members - we are lucky to have anything if you ask me, especially in these uncertain times. Fair enough if you are a developer, you want to make a profit, so reinventing the architectural wheel is simply not realistic.

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 3:02 pm
by AG
Just build it wrote:Wow, how attractive and original. :roll:

I can't believe there's a team of architects at that place that can sit down and agree that these featureless Lego monstrosities are the best they can come up with, regardless of the budget.
In a typical office building like this one, creating a building of architectural wonder doesn't often rate very high on the agenda. In fact, in many cases the design is hardly determined by the architects at all. It isn't fair to be criticising architects about the design when they are one of the many parties who have a say in the design and function of the building. It's not as simple as the developer or client simply going up to an architect and asking to them to come up with a design, then the architect doodles a design and that's the final design.

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 3:08 pm
by Ben
AG wrote:
Just build it wrote:Wow, how attractive and original. :roll:

I can't believe there's a team of architects at that place that can sit down and agree that these featureless Lego monstrosities are the best they can come up with, regardless of the budget.
In a typical office building like this one, creating a building of architectural wonder doesn't often rate very high on the agenda. In fact, in many cases the design is hardly determined by the architects at all. It isn't fair to be criticising architects about the design when they are one of the many parties who have a say in the design and function of the building. It's not as simple as the developer or client simply going up to an architect and asking to them come up with a design, then the architect doodles a design and that's the final design.
That is a fair point but if you line this tower up against CCT1, CCT2, CCT8, and 105 Waymouth St, they are all essentially the same towers externally, excepts heights and dimensions are different. The glass is the same shape and design in all towers. Yes it may have changed the colour but honestly irregardless of the budget, this is recycling the same projects over and over and we (Adelaide) deserve better quite frankly. It's plain laziness on the part of the architect. It's like a sausage factory. Same thing comes out every time.

[CAN] Re: #PRO: 71-83 Franklin Street| 47m | 12 Lvls | Office

Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 3:19 pm
by Ben
CCT8 and this are almost identical. While the others have a slight change of glass colour.

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image