Page 16 of 111

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 7:48 am
by rhino
Don't forget to put a platform around the top with a heap of hideous mobile phone tower/aerials all around it!

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 10:50 am
by Cruise
momentkiller wrote:Made my comment and I did a quick copy & paste job of the idea.

Image
i just relised how ugly the myer centre really is from that photo

whats it supposed to look like? a friggin castle?

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 12:45 pm
by Will
^^Yes, the Myer Centre is meant to look like a castle.

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 4:51 pm
by talrok
From that aerial shot, CC1 looks like it was built back in 1973 .. no James Blunt reference intended, but its very uninspiring building. I think buildings like Black Stump or the ex ING Building are far more appealing.

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 5:26 pm
by crawf
Though the quality of that photo is pretty dodgy

most of CC2 will be blocked of by the future 30,000sqm tower

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 7:37 pm
by Matt
talrok wrote:From that aerial shot, CC1 looks like it was built back in 1973 .. no James Blunt reference intended, but its very uninspiring building. I think buildings like Black Stump or the ex ING Building are far more appealing.
Couldn't agree more.

I hate hate HATE this crappy green glass that's being used everywhere.
In my opinion, CC1 and 2 look like they're still being built and the builders forgot to take the scaffolding down.
Ugly.

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 8:45 pm
by crawf
Yeah I'm starting to get sick of seeing green glass, please no more!

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2007 9:47 pm
by jk1237
Just off the topic, I love that elevated pic of the CBD. Would be great if we could do a quick helicopter ride over the city, so we could take some more pics. I wonder how much they would charge if we got a group together from here, for 30 mins over CBD

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2007 1:47 am
by Norman
Catch one of the News Copters I say :lol:

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2007 9:17 am
by Zender
Matt wrote:
talrok wrote:From that aerial shot, CC1 looks like it was built back in 1973 .. no James Blunt reference intended, but its very uninspiring building. I think buildings like Black Stump or the ex ING Building are far more appealing.
Couldn't agree more.

I hate hate HATE this crappy green glass that's being used everywhere.
In my opinion, CC1 and 2 look like they're still being built and the builders forgot to take the scaffolding down.
Ugly.
UH i can't stand CC1! for such a new building that they talk up so much, it looks pretty ugly IMO!
in the day time u can see thru all the glass and all the blinds (i think they are) are at different levels and contribute to it looking, well, unfinished. and speaking of unfinished, what is happening with the western side of it, all that concrete (and not colour matched) looks ghey. As for Viccy square, like everyone else said, we need 200+ metres. A tower of this height would look stunning towering in the 'centre' of the city (thats if anyone decides to build south of it!!!!). Obviously it should be matched by equally beautiful surrounding gardens.

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2007 9:26 am
by bm7500
jk1237 wrote:Just off the topic, I love that elevated pic of the CBD. Would be great if we could do a quick helicopter ride over the city, so we could take some more pics. I wonder how much they would charge if we got a group together from here, for 30 mins over CBD
Have a look here: http://www.heliair.com.au/html/scenic_flights.html

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2007 10:38 am
by rhino
Personally, I don't think a tower in the middle of Victoria Square is a good idea.

If we want Victoria Square to be Adelaide's main meeting place, outdoor event venue with a decent music bowl thing at one end (as in one of the proposals in the "What's Next for Victoria Square" forum), then a big tower in the middle of the square is going to be very disruptive and won't allow the square to be used for the purposes proposed in the other forum, which, personally, I think would make better use of the square.

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2007 10:49 am
by Howie
If we're planning on holding outdoor concerts there's always the under utilized riverbank precinct. I believe Victoria Square being the focal point of our entire city it should have something symbolic at it's center... like a modern day tower clock, but picture it as a single shard of glass and metal with a lighting display going up it's entirety.

It's just wrong I think to have a road going through it, with a statue in the middle like what we have currently.

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2007 11:03 am
by rhino
Howie wrote:It's just wrong I think to have a road going through it, with a statue in the middle like what we have currently.
Well in a couple of years we'll have gained plenty of experience in tunnelling. Maybe then the square can become whole.

[COM] Re: #Proposal: 97m Victoria Square Tower

Posted: Thu Nov 01, 2007 11:11 am
by Howie
I think the experience and know-how is there. We just need the willpower to do it.

Same can be said about many issues we face in the city, a recent example is that when I said buildings should be built higher than what they are currently to a friend, in which he replied, but then you've got to worry about fire escapes and stuff. Totally missed the bigger picture.